04-07-2015, 01:56 PM
Hi Walter,
Your proposal duplicates the criteria for eligibilty in 16.1 and 16.2. Wouldn't it be simpler to combine the two as I have sugested? Your proposal seems to meet the CWP first principle in these matters of being registered as SCO should carry all privileges by not having any privileges. I may be wrong, but I believe they want being registered as SCO should in itself mean you are eligible to compete for Scottish individual national championships or representing Scotland. If you add an eligibility section for registering as SCO with FIDE as Douglas has said was muted by AW to my suggestion, I believe the CWP intention are met as well as your own with perhaps the exception of people who currently are SCO but do not fulfil your other criteria.
Your proposal duplicates the criteria for eligibilty in 16.1 and 16.2. Wouldn't it be simpler to combine the two as I have sugested? Your proposal seems to meet the CWP first principle in these matters of being registered as SCO should carry all privileges by not having any privileges. I may be wrong, but I believe they want being registered as SCO should in itself mean you are eligible to compete for Scottish individual national championships or representing Scotland. If you add an eligibility section for registering as SCO with FIDE as Douglas has said was muted by AW to my suggestion, I believe the CWP intention are met as well as your own with perhaps the exception of people who currently are SCO but do not fulfil your other criteria.