10-08-2012, 06:41 PM
I was initially only discussing this on the forum - the actual motion being raised with myself as seconder came as a surprise ( abit of communication would not go amiss!). However, I think the motion itself deserves to be looked at, discussed and put to a vote.
I agree that Jacob has done a lot of good (even great!) work during hs time here in Scotland, but the fact is he also has 'used' (I don't mean this in a bad way) the system to work for his own benefit.
He doesn't represent Scotland anymore, he represents Denmark, so I don't think he should be Scottish champion - quite simple and this would be my view for anyone, not just Jacob, and in any sport not just chess. Jacob himself appears to agree with this - well, the first part.
Mike and Andrew's comments aren't particularly relevant - although Ian raises legitimate questions which need to be discussed. I would hope David also follows any debate before voting.
Personally I believe that the title of Scottish champion should entitle the winner to an automatic Olympiad team place, and this would naturally require the winner to be SCO registered. A different argument admittedly (hopefully one which will be raised and discussed at the next AGM) , but this motion is a necessary precursor in my opinion, notwithstanding its own merits.
I agree that Jacob has done a lot of good (even great!) work during hs time here in Scotland, but the fact is he also has 'used' (I don't mean this in a bad way) the system to work for his own benefit.
He doesn't represent Scotland anymore, he represents Denmark, so I don't think he should be Scottish champion - quite simple and this would be my view for anyone, not just Jacob, and in any sport not just chess. Jacob himself appears to agree with this - well, the first part.
Mike and Andrew's comments aren't particularly relevant - although Ian raises legitimate questions which need to be discussed. I would hope David also follows any debate before voting.
Personally I believe that the title of Scottish champion should entitle the winner to an automatic Olympiad team place, and this would naturally require the winner to be SCO registered. A different argument admittedly (hopefully one which will be raised and discussed at the next AGM) , but this motion is a necessary precursor in my opinion, notwithstanding its own merits.