26-11-2012, 12:14 PM
I think you may have answered your own point. Ali is strong enough to play in Division 1 of SNCL...
This was discussed before and almost unanminously rejected as it causes too many issues. What happens if your designated female player can't make it, do you lose the match.
What about players like Rosie Giulian and Elaine Bamber who are currently playing in Division 1, would you expect them to give up their places and play in Division 3 / Division 4??
The idea is not a good one as it inhibits rather than promotes. We want to be inclusive not exclusive
This was discussed before and almost unanminously rejected as it causes too many issues. What happens if your designated female player can't make it, do you lose the match.
What about players like Rosie Giulian and Elaine Bamber who are currently playing in Division 1, would you expect them to give up their places and play in Division 3 / Division 4??
The idea is not a good one as it inhibits rather than promotes. We want to be inclusive not exclusive
"How sad to see, what used to be, a model of decorum and tranquility become like any other sport, a battleground for rival ideologies to slug it out with glee"