18-01-2013, 08:39 PM
JRedpath Wrote:Sounds to me like you have some personal issues with Andy Muir that need resolved, that's fine but seems like it is affecting your judgement. You clearly had no problem with Edinburgh West playing out of grading order in the final last year, so why now? I also can't accept your reasoning for yourself playing out of order in last years final, you can't complain about others doing it when you have done yourself!
I will however agree that the rules need to be ammended to be more clear for future years. They should either say "strict published Scottish Grading Order" or "within x amount of points".
Maybe we could have an independent unbiased viewpoint from somone like Donald Wilson or Ken Stewart, we are clearly not going to agree and could cause an issue tomorrow. Best to get it sorted out now.
I'm sure there are a lot of people with personal issues against Andy Muir! It's not affecting my judgement though - I've been arguing the same point with all you guys for years now
