Results for Spens Cup 2012-13

Spens Cup 2012-13

Ending on 27/04/2013

Grading calculations last updated - 30/07/2013

Spens Cup 2012-13 League Table

								Boards
			Matches					Played			Defaults			Score
Pos	Team	Team Name	P	W	D	L	Pts	W	D	L	W	D	L	Boards	%
1	6	Kilmarnock Burns	3	3	0	0	6	7	4	1	6	0	0	15	83
2	1	Phones	3	2	0	1	4	3	7	2	6	0	0	12½	69
3	3	Kilmarnock	3	2	0	1	4	6	8	4	0	0	0	10	56
4	8	Hamilton B	3	1	1	1	3	8	3	5	0	0	2	9½	53
5	7	Irvine	2	1	0	1	2	3	4	5	0	0	0	5	42
6	4	Edinburgh Civil Service	2	0	1	1	1	2	2	6	2	0	0	5	42
7	9	Troon	2	0	0	2	0	1	4	7	0	0	0	3	25
8	2	Edinburgh B	1	0	0	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	6	0	0
9	5	East Kilbride	1	0	0	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	6	0	0
			20	9	2	9	20	30	32	30	14	0	14	61

Spens Cup 2012-13 Crosstable

Team Name 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Plyd Boards
1 Phones X 6 2                4½ 3 12½

2 Edinburgh B 0 X                      1 0

3 Kilmarnock 4    X 4    2          3 10

4 Edinburgh Civil Service       2 X          3    2 5

5 East Kilbride             X 0          1 0

6 Kilmarnock Burns       4    6 X 5       3 15

7 Irvine                1 X 4    2 5

8 Hamilton B          3       2 X 4½ 3 9½

9 Troon 1½                   1½ X 2 3

Spens Cup 2012-13 Match Results

Bd Grade Phones (1) vs (2) Edinburgh B Grade Comments

1 0 DEFAULT W - L DEFAULT 0 Win by Default

2 0 DEFAULT W - L DEFAULT 0 Win by Default

3 0 DEFAULT W - L DEFAULT 0 Win by Default

4 0 DEFAULT W - L DEFAULT 0 Win by Default

5 0 DEFAULT W - L DEFAULT 0 Win by Default

6 0 DEFAULT W - L DEFAULT 0 Win by Default

6 - 0

Bd Grade East Kilbride (5) vs (6) Kilmarnock Burns Grade Comments

1 0 DEFAULT L - W DEFAULT 0 Loss by Default

2 0 DEFAULT L - W DEFAULT 0 Loss by Default

3 0 DEFAULT L - W DEFAULT 0 Loss by Default

4 0 DEFAULT L - W DEFAULT 0 Loss by Default

5 0 DEFAULT L - W DEFAULT 0 Loss by Default

6 0 DEFAULT L - W DEFAULT 0 Loss by Default

0 - 6

Bd Grade Kilmarnock (3) vs (4) Edinburgh Civil Service Grade Comments

1 1852 Malkin, Kenneth ½ - ½ Macnab, Crawford T 1783 Draw

2 1762 Hamilton, Douglas 1 - 0 Austin, Rudolph J 1597 Home Win

3 1752 McPheator, Gary ½ - ½ Bate, Simon 1572 Draw

4 1724 Kleboe, James P R 1 - 0 Scott, Richard 1570 Home Win

5 1437 Muir, Ian 1 - 0 Heatlie, Douglas S 1564 Home Win

6 1455 Kennedy, Joe 0 - 1 Brown, Gerry 1489 Away Win

4 - 2

Bd Grade Troon (9) vs (1) Phones Grade Comments

1 1863 Barrett, Tommy ½ - ½ Dickson, Robert 1821 Draw

2 1846 Calder, John 0 - 1 Findlay, James 1744 Away Win

3 1608 Malcolm, Duncan ½ - ½ McIntyre, John W 1678 Draw

4 1596 Lampard, Alice 0 - 1 Rettie, Stephen 1650 Away Win

5 1518 Weir, J Len ½ - ½ O`Brien, Robert J 1584 Draw

6 1513 Lampard, Stuart 0 - 1 McCafferty, David 1508 Away Win

1½ - 4½

Bd Grade Irvine (7) vs (8) Hamilton B Grade Comments

1 1761 Walsh, Philip F 1 - 0 Donohue, Tom 2012 Home Win

2 1722 Birnie, Alan J 1 - 0 Mulholland, Arthur L 1665 Home Win

3 1519 Shankland, John ½ - ½ Montgomery, Robert S 1653 Draw

4 1541 Loughran, Robert 0 - 1 Montgomery, James R 1638 Away Win

5 1559 Copeland, Robert 1 - 0 Hanley, Michael 1562 Home Win

6 1556 Gourlay, Robert ½ - ½ Frame, Jim H 1197 Draw

4 - 2

Bd Grade Edinburgh Civil Service (4) vs (8) Hamilton B Grade Comments

1 1783 Macnab, Crawford T 0 - 1 Donohue, Tom 2012 Away Win

2 1597 Austin, Rudolph J 0 - 1 Montgomery, James R 1638 Away Win

3 1572 Bate, Simon 1 - 0 Mulholland, Arthur L 1665 Home Win

4 1564 Heatlie, Douglas S 0 - 1 Montgomery, Robert S 1653 Away Win

5 1489 Brown, Gerry W - L DEFAULT 0 Win by Default

6 1444 Jackson, Ralph W - L DEFAULT 0 Win by Default

3 - 3

Bd Grade Irvine (7) vs (6) Kilmarnock Burns Grade Comments

1 1761 Walsh, Philip F ½ - ½ Shaw, John K (GM) 2397 Draw

2 1722 Birnie, Alan J 0 - 1 Frew, Elliot 2059 Away Win

3 1649 King, Graeme E 0 - 1 Brown, Steven A 2030 Away Win

4 1616 Thomson, Andrew 0 - 1 Roy, Ali 1838 Away Win

5 1559 Copeland, Robert ½ - ½ Gillespie, David P 1768 Draw

6 1519 Shankland, John 0 - 1 McGovern, Patrick 1725 Away Win

1 - 5

Bd Grade Kilmarnock (3) vs (1) Phones Grade Comments

1 2163 Allor, Chukwuka 1 - 0 Dickson, Robert 1821 Home Win

2 1852 Malkin, Kenneth 1 - 0 Findlay, James 1744 Home Win

3 1798 Malkin, Jamie ½ - ½ Barker, Luke 1714 Draw

4 1762 Hamilton, Douglas ½ - ½ McIntyre, John W 1678 Draw

5 1724 Kleboe, James P R ½ - ½ Rettie, Stephen 1650 Draw

6 1558 Armour, James W ½ - ½ Paterson, Colin C 1495 Draw

4 - 2

Bd Grade Kilmarnock Burns (6) vs (3) Kilmarnock Grade Comments

1 2397 Shaw, John K (GM) 1 - 0 Allor, Chukwuka 2163 Home Win

2 2059 Frew, Elliot 1 - 0 Malkin, Kenneth 1852 Home Win

3 2030 Brown, Steven A 0 - 1 Malkin, Jamie 1798 Away Win

4 1838 Roy, Ali ½ - ½ Hamilton, Douglas 1762 Draw

5 1844 Parks, Joe ½ - ½ Kleboe, James P R 1724 Draw

6 1768 Gillespie, David P 1 - 0 Armour, James W 1558 Home Win

4 - 2

Bd Grade Troon (9) vs (8) Hamilton B Grade Comments

1 1846 Calder, John ½ - ½ Tweedie, Christopher 2066 Draw

2 1513 Lampard, Stuart 0 - 1 Thomas, Phil 1858 Away Win

3 1490 Smith, Cameron L 1 - 0 McCusker, Andrew 1619 Home Win

4 1438 Park, Frank 0 - 1 Montgomery, James R 1638 Away Win

5 1165 Wainright, Jim 0 - 1 Mulholland, Arthur L 1665 Away Win

6 1073 Smith, Alex 0 - 1 Montgomery, Robert S 1653 Away Win

1½ - 4½

Spens Cup 2012-13 Team Results

Team 1 - Phones
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
1 Dickson, Robert PO - 1821 3731 ½ 2 2013 ½ 2 0.563 -0.063 1820

6 McCafferty, David POTR - 1508 4945 1 1 1513 1 1 0.493 0.507 1913

3 McIntyre, John W PO - 1678 5102 1 2 1685 1 2 0.980 0.020 1685

5 O`Brien, Robert J LGPA - 1584 5515 ½ 1 1518 ½ 1 0.591 -0.091 1518

8 Paterson, Colin C PO - 1495 5582 ½ 1 1558 ½ 1 0.409 0.091 1558

4 Rettie, Stephen POGR - 1650 5763 1½ 2 1692 1½ 2 0.882 0.618 1886

2 Findlay, James PO - 1744 6698 1 2 1849 1 2 0.714 0.286 1849

7 Barker, Luke POGM - 1714 11947 ½ 1 1818 ½ 1 0.357 0.143 1818

Team 3 - Kilmarnock
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
9 Armour, James W KM - 1558 3073 ½ 2 1652 ½ 2 0.783 -0.283 1458

2 Hamilton, Douglas KM - 1762 4236 2 3 1719 2 3 1.671 0.329 1841

6 Kennedy, Joe KM - 1455 4560 0 1 1489 0 1 0.451 -0.451 1089

4 Kleboe, James P R KM - 1724 4611 2 3 1688 2 3 1.646 0.354 1810

3 McPheator, Gary PWIC - 1752 5217 ½ 1 1572 ½ 1 0.735 -0.235 1572

5 Muir, Ian KM - 1437 5401 1 1 1564 1 1 0.331 0.669 1964

1 Malkin, Kenneth KM - 1852 7619 1½ 3 1862 1½ 3 1.485 0.015 1862

8 Malkin, Jamie KM J20 1798 14049 1½ 2 1872 1½ 2 0.829 0.671 2065

7 Allor, Chukwuka SH - 2163 22880 1 2 2109 1 2 1.088 -0.088 2109

Team 4 - Edinburgh Civil Service
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
2 Austin, Rudolph J CS - 1597 3084 0 2 1700 0 2 0.727 -0.727 1300

3 Bate, Simon CS - 1572 3143 1½ 2 1708 1½ 2 0.635 0.865 1902

5 Heatlie, Douglas S CSED - 1564 4313 0 2 1545 0 2 1.046 -1.046 1145

1 Macnab, Crawford T CS - 1783 4810 ½ 2 1932 ½ 2 0.615 -0.115 1739

4 Scott, Richard CS - 1570 5921 0 1 1724 0 1 0.295 -0.295 1324

6 Brown, Gerry CS - 1489 7921 2 2 1455 1 1 0.549 0.451 1855

7 Jackson, Ralph CS - 1444 11978 1 1    0 0 0.000 0.000 -

Team 6 - Kilmarnock Burns
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
3 Brown, Steven A GMAR - 2030 3319 1 2 1734 1 2 1.675 -0.675 1734

6 McGovern, Patrick GD - 1725 5063 1 1 1519 1 1 0.762 0.238 1919

7 Parks, Joe KM - 1844 5575 ½ 1 1724 ½ 1 0.663 -0.163 1724

1 Shaw, John K (GM) KMPY - 2397 5961 1½ 2 2080 1½ 2 1.711 -0.211 2273

2 Frew, Elliot GD - 2059 7506 2 2 1787 2 2 1.640 0.360 2187

4 Roy, Ali CK J17 1838 14894 1½ 2 1689 1½ 2 1.381 0.119 1882

5 Gillespie, David P IR J18 1768 17274 1½ 2 1558 1½ 2 1.534 -0.034 1752

Team 7 - Irvine
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
2 Birnie, Alan J IR - 1722 3199 1 2 1862 1 2 0.699 0.301 1862

7 King, Graeme E IRPY - 1649 4597 0 1 2030 0 1 0.092 -0.092 1630

4 Loughran, Robert IR - 1541 4725 0 1 1638 0 1 0.370 -0.370 1238

3 Shankland, John IR - 1519 5949 ½ 2 1689 ½ 2 0.556 -0.056 1496

8 Thomson, Andrew IR - 1616 6234 0 1 1883 0 1 0.178 -0.178 1483

1 Walsh, Philip F IR - 1761 6369 1½ 2 2086 1½ 2 0.274 1.226 2280

6 Gourlay, Robert KIIR - 1556 7499 ½ 1 1197 ½ 1 0.894 -0.394 1197

5 Copeland, Robert IR - 1559 16666 1½ 2 1685 1½ 2 0.685 0.815 1878

Team 8 - Hamilton B
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
6 Frame, Jim H HA - 1197 3977 ½ 1 1556 ½ 1 0.106 0.394 1556

5 Hanley, Michael HA - 1562 4248 0 1 1559 0 1 0.507 -0.507 1159

3 Montgomery, Robert S HABK - 1653 5335 2½ 3 1445 2½ 3 2.223 0.277 1725

2 Mulholland, Arthur L HA - 1665 5404 1 3 1520 1 3 1.971 -0.971 1398

9 Tweedie, Christopher HA - 2066 9122 ½ 1 1846 ½ 1 0.777 -0.277 1846

1 Donohue, Tom HA - 2012 14200 1 2 1772 1 2 1.596 -0.596 1772

4 Montgomery, James R HA - 1638 14510 3 3 1525 3 3 1.943 1.057 1925

8 Thomas, Phil EKTR - 1858 15971 1 1 1513 1 1 0.885 0.115 1913

7 McCusker, Andrew HA J14 1619 21604 0 1 1490 0 1 0.676 -0.676 1090

Team 9 - Troon
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
1 Barrett, Tommy TRIR - 1863 3137 ½ 1 1821 ½ 1 0.556 -0.056 1821

3 Malcolm, Duncan TR - 1608 4847 ½ 1 1678 ½ 1 0.403 0.097 1678

8 Park, Frank TR - 1438 5568 0 1 1638 0 1 0.243 -0.243 1238

7 Smith, Cameron L TR - 1490 6026 1 1 1719 1 1 0.212 0.788 2119

5 Weir, J Len TR - 1518 6435 ½ 1 1584 ½ 1 0.409 0.091 1584

2 Calder, John TRIC - 1846 7142 ½ 2 1905 ½ 2 0.859 -0.359 1712

9 Wainright, Jim TR - 1165 7802 0 1 1565 0 1 0.082 -0.082 1165

10 Smith, Alex TR - 1073 14697 0 1 1473 0 1 0.082 -0.082 1073

6 Lampard, Stuart TR - 1513 15793 0 2 1683 0 2 0.622 -0.622 1283

4 Lampard, Alice TR J16 1596 16273 0 1 1650 0 1 0.423 -0.423 1250

Bd	Grade	Phones	(1)	vs	(2)	Edinburgh B	Grade	Comments
1	0	DEFAULT	W	-	L	DEFAULT	0	Win by Default
2	0	DEFAULT	W	-	L	DEFAULT	0	Win by Default
3	0	DEFAULT	W	-	L	DEFAULT	0	Win by Default
4	0	DEFAULT	W	-	L	DEFAULT	0	Win by Default
5	0	DEFAULT	W	-	L	DEFAULT	0	Win by Default
6	0	DEFAULT	W	-	L	DEFAULT	0	Win by Default
			6	-	0

Bd	Grade	East Kilbride	(5)	vs	(6)	Kilmarnock Burns	Grade	Comments
1	0	DEFAULT	L	-	W	DEFAULT	0	Loss by Default
2	0	DEFAULT	L	-	W	DEFAULT	0	Loss by Default
3	0	DEFAULT	L	-	W	DEFAULT	0	Loss by Default
4	0	DEFAULT	L	-	W	DEFAULT	0	Loss by Default
5	0	DEFAULT	L	-	W	DEFAULT	0	Loss by Default
6	0	DEFAULT	L	-	W	DEFAULT	0	Loss by Default
			0	-	6

Bd	Grade	Kilmarnock	(3)	vs	(4)	Edinburgh Civil Service	Grade	Comments
1	1852	Malkin, Kenneth	½	-	½	Macnab, Crawford T	1783	Draw
2	1762	Hamilton, Douglas	1	-	0	Austin, Rudolph J	1597	Home Win
3	1752	McPheator, Gary	½	-	½	Bate, Simon	1572	Draw
4	1724	Kleboe, James P R	1	-	0	Scott, Richard	1570	Home Win
5	1437	Muir, Ian	1	-	0	Heatlie, Douglas S	1564	Home Win
6	1455	Kennedy, Joe	0	-	1	Brown, Gerry	1489	Away Win
			4	-	2

Bd	Grade	Troon	(9)	vs	(1)	Phones	Grade	Comments
1	1863	Barrett, Tommy	½	-	½	Dickson, Robert	1821	Draw
2	1846	Calder, John	0	-	1	Findlay, James	1744	Away Win
3	1608	Malcolm, Duncan	½	-	½	McIntyre, John W	1678	Draw
4	1596	Lampard, Alice	0	-	1	Rettie, Stephen	1650	Away Win
5	1518	Weir, J Len	½	-	½	O`Brien, Robert J	1584	Draw
6	1513	Lampard, Stuart	0	-	1	McCafferty, David	1508	Away Win
			1½	-	4½

Bd	Grade	Irvine	(7)	vs	(8)	Hamilton B	Grade	Comments
1	1761	Walsh, Philip F	1	-	0	Donohue, Tom	2012	Home Win
2	1722	Birnie, Alan J	1	-	0	Mulholland, Arthur L	1665	Home Win
3	1519	Shankland, John	½	-	½	Montgomery, Robert S	1653	Draw
4	1541	Loughran, Robert	0	-	1	Montgomery, James R	1638	Away Win
5	1559	Copeland, Robert	1	-	0	Hanley, Michael	1562	Home Win
6	1556	Gourlay, Robert	½	-	½	Frame, Jim H	1197	Draw
			4	-	2

Bd	Grade	Irvine	(7)	vs	(6)	Kilmarnock Burns	Grade	Comments
1	1761	Walsh, Philip F	½	-	½	Shaw, John K (GM)	2397	Draw
2	1722	Birnie, Alan J	0	-	1	Frew, Elliot	2059	Away Win
3	1649	King, Graeme E	0	-	1	Brown, Steven A	2030	Away Win
4	1616	Thomson, Andrew	0	-	1	Roy, Ali	1838	Away Win
5	1559	Copeland, Robert	½	-	½	Gillespie, David P	1768	Draw
6	1519	Shankland, John	0	-	1	McGovern, Patrick	1725	Away Win
			1	-	5

Bd	Grade	Kilmarnock	(3)	vs	(1)	Phones	Grade	Comments
1	2163	Allor, Chukwuka	1	-	0	Dickson, Robert	1821	Home Win
2	1852	Malkin, Kenneth	1	-	0	Findlay, James	1744	Home Win
3	1798	Malkin, Jamie	½	-	½	Barker, Luke	1714	Draw
4	1762	Hamilton, Douglas	½	-	½	McIntyre, John W	1678	Draw
5	1724	Kleboe, James P R	½	-	½	Rettie, Stephen	1650	Draw
6	1558	Armour, James W	½	-	½	Paterson, Colin C	1495	Draw
			4	-	2

Bd	Grade	Troon	(9)	vs	(8)	Hamilton B	Grade	Comments
1	1846	Calder, John	½	-	½	Tweedie, Christopher	2066	Draw
2	1513	Lampard, Stuart	0	-	1	Thomas, Phil	1858	Away Win
3	1490	Smith, Cameron L	1	-	0	McCusker, Andrew	1619	Home Win
4	1438	Park, Frank	0	-	1	Montgomery, James R	1638	Away Win
5	1165	Wainright, Jim	0	-	1	Mulholland, Arthur L	1665	Away Win
6	1073	Smith, Alex	0	-	1	Montgomery, Robert S	1653	Away Win
			1½	-	4½

Team 1 - Phones
								Grading Performance
Pool	Name	Club	Status	Grade	PNUM	Pts	Plyd	Opps	Act	Plyd	Exp	Diff	Perf
1	Dickson, Robert	PO	-	1821	3731	½	2	2013	½	2	0.563	-0.063	1820
6	McCafferty, David	POTR	-	1508	4945	1	1	1513	1	1	0.493	0.507	1913
3	McIntyre, John W	PO	-	1678	5102	1	2	1685	1	2	0.980	0.020	1685
5	O`Brien, Robert J	LGPA	-	1584	5515	½	1	1518	½	1	0.591	-0.091	1518
8	Paterson, Colin C	PO	-	1495	5582	½	1	1558	½	1	0.409	0.091	1558
4	Rettie, Stephen	POGR	-	1650	5763	1½	2	1692	1½	2	0.882	0.618	1886
2	Findlay, James	PO	-	1744	6698	1	2	1849	1	2	0.714	0.286	1849
7	Barker, Luke	POGM	-	1714	11947	½	1	1818	½	1	0.357	0.143	1818