Results for Spens Cup

Spens Cup

Ending on 19/04/2014

Grading calculations last updated - 19/07/2014

Spens Cup League Table

								Boards
			Matches					Played			Defaults			Score
Pos	Team	Team Name	P	W	D	L	Pts	W	D	L	W	D	L	Boards	%
1	1	Irvine	3	3	0	0	6	6	4	5	3	0	0	11	61
2	3	Edinburgh Civil Service	3	2	0	1	4	7	6	4	1	0	0	11	61
3	8	Troon	3	1	1	1	3	7	7	4	0	0	0	10½	58
4	4	Kilmarnock A	2	1	0	1	2	5	1	3	0	0	3	5½	46
5	5	Hamilton	2	0	1	1	1	4	3	4	0	0	1	5½	46
6	6	Dunbar	2	0	1	1	1	2	4	6	0	0	0	4	33
7	2	Kilmarnock B	2	0	0	2	0	1	5	6	0	0	0	3½	29
8	7	Phones	1	0	1	0	1	2	2	2	0	0	0	3	50
			18	7	4	7	18	34	32	34	4	0	4	55

Spens Cup Crosstable

Team Name 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Plyd Boards
1 Irvine X 3½    4 3½          3 11

2 Kilmarnock B 2½ X 1                2 3½

3 Edinburgh Civil Service    5 X 2½          3½ 3 11

4 Kilmarnock A 2    3½ X             2 5½

5 Hamilton 2½          X 3       2 5½

6 Dunbar             3 X    1 2 4

7 Phones                   X 3 1 3

8 Troon       2½       5 3 X 3 10½

Spens Cup Match Results

Bd Grade Irvine (1) vs (2) Kilmarnock B Grade Comments

1 1888 Gillespie, David P 1 - 0 McNicoll, John D 1518 Home Win

2 1677 King, Graeme E ½ - ½ Armour, James W 1515 Draw

3 1570 Copeland, Robert 1 - 0 Strong, Colin A 1453 Home Win

4 1482 Loughran, Robert ½ - ½ Muir, Ian 1441 Draw

5 1367 Gourlay, Robert 0 - 1 Henderson, Roy 1265 Away Win

6 1378 Locke, Robert ½ - ½ McCormick, Ron J 1225 Draw

3½ - 2½

Bd Grade Edinburgh Civil Service (3) vs (4) Kilmarnock A Grade Comments

1 1854 Prince, Alan R W - L Allor, Chukwuka 2074 Win by Default

2 1805 Macnab, Crawford T ½ - ½ Parks, Joe 1822 Draw

3 1720 Austin, Rudolph J 0 - 1 Malkin, Kenneth 1822 Away Win

4 1571 Scott, Richard 0 - 1 Hilton, Steve H 1822 Away Win

5 1563 Heatlie, Douglas S 0 - 1 Hamilton, Douglas 1776 Away Win

6 1552 Bate, Simon 1 - 0 Kleboe, James P R 1760 Home Win

2½ - 3½

Bd Grade Hamilton (5) vs (6) Dunbar Grade Comments

1 1976 Donohue, Tom 1 - 0 James, Chris 1811 Home Win

2 1666 Montgomery, James R 0 - 1 Carter, Richard G 1736 Away Win

3 1662 Montgomery, Robert S 1 - 0 Livingstone, Jonathan 1656 Home Win

4 1213 Drummond, James ½ - ½ Banaghan, Frank 1585 Draw

5 1160 Airlie, Bernard ½ - ½ Bell, Alan 1399 Draw

6 1108 Perrie, Bill 0 - 1 Banaghan, Alice 1170 Away Win

3 - 3

Bd Grade Phones (7) vs (8) Troon Grade Comments

1 1806 Dickson, Robert 1 - 0 Calder, John 1880 Home Win

2 1638 McIntyre, John W ½ - ½ Templeton, Robin 1837 Draw

3 1576 MacDonald, Paul H 1 - 0 Barrett, Tommy 1832 Home Win

4 1564 O`Brien, Robert J 0 - 1 Baird, Clive H 1734 Away Win

5 1466 Paterson, Colin C 0 - 1 Malcolm, Duncan 1618 Away Win

6 1416 Trantor, Ewan ½ - ½ Lampard, Alice 1582 Draw

3 - 3

Bd Grade Troon (8) vs (6) Dunbar Grade Comments

1 1880 Calder, John 1 - 0 James, Chris 1811 Home Win

2 1832 Barrett, Tommy ½ - ½ Carter, Richard G 1736 Draw

3 1582 Lampard, Alice 1 - 0 Banaghan, Frank 1585 Home Win

4 1510 Lampard, Stuart ½ - ½ Adams, David J 1513 Draw

5 1570 Smith, Cameron L 1 - 0 Banaghan, Alice 1170 Home Win

6 1534 Weir, J Len 1 - 0 Maley, Darren 0 Home Win

5 - 1

Bd Grade Kilmarnock A (4) vs (1) Irvine Grade Comments

1 2074 Allor, Chukwuka 0 - 1 Gillespie, David P 1888 Away Win

2 1958 Malkin, Jamie L - W Walsh, Philip F 1806 Loss by Default

3 1822 Parks, Joe 1 - 0 King, Graeme E 1677 Home Win

4 1776 Hamilton, Douglas 1 - 0 Thomson, Andrew 1599 Home Win

5 1822 Malkin, Kenneth L - W Copeland, Robert 1570 Loss by Default

6 1760 Kleboe, James P R 0 - 1 Loughran, Robert 1482 Away Win

2 - 4

Bd Grade Edinburgh Civil Service (3) vs (2) Kilmarnock B Grade Comments

1 1720 Austin, Rudolph J 1 - 0 McNicoll, John D 1518 Home Win

2 1571 Scott, Richard 1 - 0 Armour, James W 1515 Home Win

3 1563 Heatlie, Douglas S 1 - 0 Strong, Colin A 1453 Home Win

4 1552 Bate, Simon ½ - ½ Muir, Ian 1441 Draw

5 1486 Brown, Gerry 1 - 0 Henderson, Roy 1265 Home Win

6 1286 Anderson, George C ½ - ½ Grey, Alan 1000 Draw

5 - 1

Bd Grade Hamilton (5) vs (1) Irvine Grade Comments

1 1822 Thomas, Phil 1 - 0 Gillespie, David P 1888 Home Win

2 1666 Montgomery, James R 1 - 0 Thomson, Andrew 1599 Home Win

3 1662 Montgomery, Robert S 0 - 1 Copeland, Robert 1570 Away Win

4 1660 Houston, David 0 - 1 Loughran, Robert 1482 Away Win

5 1600 Mulholland, Arthur L ½ - ½ Teaz, Brian 1370 Draw

6 0 DEFAULT L - W Gourlay, Robert 1367 Loss by Default

2½ - 3½

Bd Grade Edinburgh Civil Service (3) vs (8) Troon Grade Comments

1 1805 Macnab, Crawford T ½ - ½ Calder, John 1880 Draw

2 1804 Anderson, Neil J ½ - ½ Barrett, Tommy 1832 Draw

3 1720 Austin, Rudolph J 1 - 0 Baird, Clive H 1734 Home Win

4 1563 Heatlie, Douglas S 0 - 1 Lampard, Alice 1582 Away Win

5 1552 Bate, Simon ½ - ½ Smith, Cameron L 1570 Draw

6 1470 Jackson, Ralph 1 - 0 Lampard, Stuart 1510 Home Win

3½ - 2½

Spens Cup Team Results

Team 1 - Irvine
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
2 King, Graeme E IRPY - 1677 4597 ½ 2 1668 ½ 2 1.018 -0.518 1476

6 Locke, Robert IR - 1378 4710 ½ 1 1225 ½ 1 0.705 -0.205 1225

4 Loughran, Robert IR - 1482 4725 2½ 3 1620 2½ 3 0.987 1.513 1900

8 Thomson, Andrew IR - 1599 6234 0 2 1721 0 2 0.680 -0.680 1321

7 Walsh, Philip F IR - 1806 6369 1 1    0 0 0.000 0.000 -

5 Gourlay, Robert KIIR - 1367 7499 1 2 1265 0 1 0.636 -0.636 865

3 Copeland, Robert IR - 1570 16666 3 3 1558 2 2 1.033 0.967 1957

1 Gillespie, David P IR J19 1888 17274 2 3 1805 2 3 1.752 0.248 1927

9 Teaz, Brian IR - 1370 24865 ½ 1 1600 ½ 1 0.212 0.288 1600

Team 2 - Kilmarnock B
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
2 Armour, James W KM - 1515 3073 ½ 2 1624 ½ 2 0.712 -0.212 1431

6 McCormick, Ron J KM - 1225 4985 ½ 1 1378 ½ 1 0.295 0.205 1378

1 McNicoll, John D KM - 1518 5209 0 2 1819 0 2 0.325 -0.325 1419

4 Muir, Ian KM - 1441 5401 1 2 1517 1 2 0.794 0.206 1517

3 Strong, Colin A KM - 1453 8401 0 2 1566 0 2 0.694 -0.694 1166

7 Grey, Alan KM - 1000 20058 ½ 1 1286 ½ 1 0.161 0.339 1286

5 Henderson, Roy KM - 1265 24787 1 2 1426 1 2 0.587 0.413 1426

Team 3 - Edinburgh Civil Service
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
8 Anderson, George C CS - 1286 3046 ½ 1 1000 ½ 1 0.839 -0.339 1000

9 Anderson, Neil J CS - 1804 3053 ½ 1 1832 ½ 1 0.458 0.042 1832

3 Austin, Rudolph J CS - 1720 3084 2 3 1691 2 3 1.600 0.400 1813

6 Bate, Simon CS - 1552 3143 2 3 1590 2 3 1.355 0.645 1712

5 Heatlie, Douglas S CSED - 1563 4313 1 3 1619 1 3 1.287 -0.287 1497

2 Macnab, Crawford T CS - 1805 4810 1 2 1851 1 2 0.875 0.125 1851

4 Scott, Richard CS - 1571 5921 1 2 1668 1 2 0.769 0.231 1668

7 Brown, Gerry CS - 1486 7921 1 1 1265 1 1 0.777 0.223 1665

1 Prince, Alan R CS - 1854 10488 1 1    0 0 0.000 0.000 -

10 Jackson, Ralph CS - 1470 11978 1 1 1510 1 1 0.444 0.556 1910

Team 4 - Kilmarnock A
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
5 Hamilton, Douglas KM - 1776 4236 2 2 1581 2 2 1.501 0.499 1981

4 Hilton, Steve H ICLG - 1822 4357 1 1 1571 1 1 0.808 0.192 1971

6 Kleboe, James P R KM - 1760 4611 0 2 1517 0 2 1.601 -1.601 1117

2 Parks, Joe KM - 1822 5575 1½ 2 1741 1½ 2 1.214 0.286 1934

3 Malkin, Kenneth KM - 1822 7619 1 2 1720 1 1 0.636 0.364 2120

7 Malkin, Jamie KM - 1958 14049 0 1    0 0 0.000 0.000 -

1 Allor, Chukwuka KMSP - 2074 22880 0 2 1923 0 1 0.699 -0.699 1523

Team 5 - Hamilton
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
3 Montgomery, Robert S HABK - 1662 5335 1 2 1626 1 2 1.095 -0.095 1626

9 Mulholland, Arthur L HA - 1600 5404 ½ 1 1370 ½ 1 0.788 -0.288 1370

1 Donohue, Tom HA - 1976 14200 1 1 1811 1 1 0.717 0.283 2211

2 Montgomery, James R HA - 1666 14510 1 2 1668 1 2 0.994 0.006 1668

5 Airlie, Bernard LKHA - 1160 15322 ½ 1 1399 ½ 1 0.202 0.298 1399

7 Thomas, Phil HATR - 1822 15971 1 1 1923 1 1 0.364 0.636 2323

6 Perrie, Bill HALK - 1108 18493 0 1 1170 0 1 0.416 -0.416 770

4 Drummond, James HA - 1213 23390 ½ 1 1585 ½ 1 0.099 0.401 1585

8 Houston, David HA - 1660 25240 0 1 1482 0 1 0.735 -0.735 1082

Team 6 - Dunbar
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
4 Banaghan, Frank DR - 1585 3113 ½ 2 1420 ½ 2 1.345 -0.845 1227

6 Banaghan, Alice DR - 1170 3480 1 2 1339 1 2 0.666 0.334 1339

2 Carter, Richard G WDDR - 1736 7590 1½ 2 1749 1½ 2 0.967 0.533 1942

5 Bell, Alan DR - 1399 16034 ½ 1 1160 ½ 1 0.798 -0.298 1160

1 James, Chris DR - 1811 18892 0 2 1928 0 2 0.686 -0.686 1528

8 Adams, David J DR - 1513 22819 ½ 1 1510 ½ 1 0.507 -0.007 1510

3 Livingstone, Jonathan DR NEW 1656 24397 0 1 1662 0 1 0.493 -0.493 1262

7 Maley, Darren DR - 0 24821 0 1 1523 0 1 0 0 1123

Team 7 - Phones
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
1 Dickson, Robert PO - 1806 3731 1 1 1880 1 1 0.396 0.604 2280

2 McIntyre, John W PO - 1638 5102 ½ 1 1837 ½ 1 0.243 0.257 1837

4 O`Brien, Robert J LGPA - 1564 5515 0 1 1734 0 1 0.277 -0.277 1334

5 Paterson, Colin C PO - 1466 5582 0 1 1618 0 1 0.301 -0.301 1218

3 MacDonald, Paul H GDPO - 1576 11408 1 1 1832 1 1 0.187 0.813 2232

6 Trantor, Ewan PO NEW 1416 22100 ½ 1 1627 ½ 1 0.233 0.267 1627

Team 8 - Troon
Grading Performance
Pool Name Club Status Grade PNUM Pts Plyd Opps Act Plyd Exp Diff Perf
4 Baird, Clive H TR - 1734 3096 1 2 1642 1 2 1.244 -0.244 1642

3 Barrett, Tommy TRIR - 1832 3137 1 3 1705 1 3 1.985 -0.985 1583

5 Malcolm, Duncan TR - 1618 4847 1 1 1466 1 1 0.699 0.301 1866

8 Smith, Cameron L TR - 1570 6026 1½ 2 1361 1½ 2 1.446 0.054 1554

2 Templeton, Robin GMTR - 1837 6218 ½ 1 1638 ½ 1 0.757 -0.257 1638

9 Weir, J Len TR - 1534 6435 1 1 1134 1 1 0.918 0.082 1534

1 Calder, John TRIC - 1880 7142 1½ 3 1807 1½ 3 1.805 -0.305 1807

7 Lampard, Stuart TR - 1510 15793 ½ 2 1492 ½ 2 1.049 -0.549 1298

6 Lampard, Alice TR J17 1582 16273 2½ 3 1530 2½ 3 1.708 0.792 1810

Bd	Grade	Irvine	(1)	vs	(2)	Kilmarnock B	Grade	Comments
1	1888	Gillespie, David P	1	-	0	McNicoll, John D	1518	Home Win
2	1677	King, Graeme E	½	-	½	Armour, James W	1515	Draw
3	1570	Copeland, Robert	1	-	0	Strong, Colin A	1453	Home Win
4	1482	Loughran, Robert	½	-	½	Muir, Ian	1441	Draw
5	1367	Gourlay, Robert	0	-	1	Henderson, Roy	1265	Away Win
6	1378	Locke, Robert	½	-	½	McCormick, Ron J	1225	Draw
			3½	-	2½

Bd	Grade	Edinburgh Civil Service	(3)	vs	(4)	Kilmarnock A	Grade	Comments
1	1854	Prince, Alan R	W	-	L	Allor, Chukwuka	2074	Win by Default
2	1805	Macnab, Crawford T	½	-	½	Parks, Joe	1822	Draw
3	1720	Austin, Rudolph J	0	-	1	Malkin, Kenneth	1822	Away Win
4	1571	Scott, Richard	0	-	1	Hilton, Steve H	1822	Away Win
5	1563	Heatlie, Douglas S	0	-	1	Hamilton, Douglas	1776	Away Win
6	1552	Bate, Simon	1	-	0	Kleboe, James P R	1760	Home Win
			2½	-	3½

Bd	Grade	Hamilton	(5)	vs	(6)	Dunbar	Grade	Comments
1	1976	Donohue, Tom	1	-	0	James, Chris	1811	Home Win
2	1666	Montgomery, James R	0	-	1	Carter, Richard G	1736	Away Win
3	1662	Montgomery, Robert S	1	-	0	Livingstone, Jonathan	1656	Home Win
4	1213	Drummond, James	½	-	½	Banaghan, Frank	1585	Draw
5	1160	Airlie, Bernard	½	-	½	Bell, Alan	1399	Draw
6	1108	Perrie, Bill	0	-	1	Banaghan, Alice	1170	Away Win
			3	-	3

Bd	Grade	Phones	(7)	vs	(8)	Troon	Grade	Comments
1	1806	Dickson, Robert	1	-	0	Calder, John	1880	Home Win
2	1638	McIntyre, John W	½	-	½	Templeton, Robin	1837	Draw
3	1576	MacDonald, Paul H	1	-	0	Barrett, Tommy	1832	Home Win
4	1564	O`Brien, Robert J	0	-	1	Baird, Clive H	1734	Away Win
5	1466	Paterson, Colin C	0	-	1	Malcolm, Duncan	1618	Away Win
6	1416	Trantor, Ewan	½	-	½	Lampard, Alice	1582	Draw
			3	-	3

Bd	Grade	Hamilton	(5)	vs	(1)	Irvine	Grade	Comments
1	1822	Thomas, Phil	1	-	0	Gillespie, David P	1888	Home Win
2	1666	Montgomery, James R	1	-	0	Thomson, Andrew	1599	Home Win
3	1662	Montgomery, Robert S	0	-	1	Copeland, Robert	1570	Away Win
4	1660	Houston, David	0	-	1	Loughran, Robert	1482	Away Win
5	1600	Mulholland, Arthur L	½	-	½	Teaz, Brian	1370	Draw
6	0	DEFAULT	L	-	W	Gourlay, Robert	1367	Loss by Default
			2½	-	3½

Team 1 - Irvine
								Grading Performance
Pool	Name	Club	Status	Grade	PNUM	Pts	Plyd	Opps	Act	Plyd	Exp	Diff	Perf
2	King, Graeme E	IRPY	-	1677	4597	½	2	1668	½	2	1.018	-0.518	1476
6	Locke, Robert	IR	-	1378	4710	½	1	1225	½	1	0.705	-0.205	1225
4	Loughran, Robert	IR	-	1482	4725	2½	3	1620	2½	3	0.987	1.513	1900
8	Thomson, Andrew	IR	-	1599	6234	0	2	1721	0	2	0.680	-0.680	1321
7	Walsh, Philip F	IR	-	1806	6369	1	1		0	0	0.000	0.000	-
5	Gourlay, Robert	KIIR	-	1367	7499	1	2	1265	0	1	0.636	-0.636	865
3	Copeland, Robert	IR	-	1570	16666	3	3	1558	2	2	1.033	0.967	1957
1	Gillespie, David P	IR	J19	1888	17274	2	3	1805	2	3	1.752	0.248	1927
9	Teaz, Brian	IR	-	1370	24865	½	1	1600	½	1	0.212	0.288	1600